Tuesday, March 01, 2005
Emotions run high during storm...my editorial response
Jason Samenow @ 12:04 AM
If we see anything over 2" out of this I will be surprised.Greg wrote:
This storm sucks! I am very discouraged and have lost all faith in the WEATHER GODS... Could it be that this could be the biggest bust of them all???By mid afternoon, some posters began attacking the competence of forecasters. RJ wrote:
I'd say our local mets get snow forecast 50% wrong 7 out of 10 times. That's just unexceptable. It's really disgraceful, sorry but I'm not going to shut up about this one.[My comment: That's a big exaggeration.]It was not until late afternoon that the flames really started to fly. A poster by the name of Rocker, let us have it:
As of 7:45 a.m. today you were predicting 4-8 inches in DC!!! As of 9 a.m. you were promising it's coming ... Truly, sadly, pathetic and a waste of time. Less power to you. [My comment: Let the record show it snowed 4-6". The snow came.]Rocker also made the bizarre accusation that we were purposefully overhyping the storm to influence decision makers to shutdown schools and offices. If only we had that influence :)
It's true that the pros were wrong -- but what I read here was the most alarmist/wishful-thinking b.s. anywhere. It's the repeated exhortations of "It's coming!! It's coming!!!" that are the problem. [My comment: Let me address a misconception I've seen perpetuated in the comments. There is this notion that we are 'amateurs' and not pros at CapitalWeather. As a matter of fact, three of CapitalWeather.com's forecasters, including myself, have advanced degrees in meteorology.]
This site has no accountability and the purported forecasters feel they have the right do the equivalent of shouting "fire" in a crowded theater."[My comment: we do post mortem forecast evaluations after every storm and most certainly point out our own mistakes. Furthermore, we are accountable in that every single forecast we do is archived and available for folks to review -- there's no hiding from our mistakes]